Does anyone else find it weird that Theodore is in Animal Parade? I just barely noticed yesterday. First Magical Melody, then DS Cute(especially when he somehow breaks into your house on the Winter/Christmasish holiday).... and now Animal Parade. I like him and all.. but I feel like he's been stalking me the last few games I've played and it scares me. O.o; Does he kinda scare anyone else?

You mean Mayor Thomas? 'Cause if you do...man, he's annoying. I tryed about five times to not call my dog off him at the start of HMDS, before I realised that attempting to harm an annoying guy in a red suit is wrong. So Santas safe this year! XD
Yes, he's a stalker. But thank goodness he isn't in IoH. I'm safe!

xD Oh.. I think they might be the same people..just with different names in different games.
Oh, I'm pretty sure he's in Ioh.. we just can't see him D:

Now that you mention it, I do sometimes think I see a shadow in the trees around the island sometimes. I thought it was Shea. Now I know the truth!!! *screams*

Theodore has several names, along with Hamilton and Thomas. They're a little bit different in each game; for example, in HM64, Thomas had a wife, and a daughter, Mary. In Magical Melody, he had a daughter, Maria. In both Tree of Tranquility and Animal Parade, he had a son, Gill.

It's really the same character, though, and he serves the same purpose in each game.

I think I like the Hamilton version... though. He seems cool. Plus.. He's related to Gill, so he can't be all that bad.

Hamilton is cool! But his name reminds me of the pig from Maggie and the Fericious Beast hehe (the pig's name was Hamilton)